Audiovisual refresh: a decision matrix for renewing video conferencing rooms

Reading time: 6 minutes

Overview of video conferencing devices – displays, cameras, video bars and controllers

When preparing the budget for your meeting rooms, you have a list of devices in front of you, their age and your colleagues’ requests. One room has a fault, another is now used differently, and for a third you don’t know how long the equipment will remain supported. For IT, facilities and whoever is responsible for the budget, the shared question now is: what to renew, to what extent, and what still needs to be found out before ordering?

Plan an AV refresh, that is, the renewal of audiovisual equipment, according to the documented condition and the required use of each room. Separate a confirmed problem from a change in requirements and from missing information. Only then compare keeping, repairing, partially renewing and fully replacing. The following matrix is a working recommendation for the buyer. It will help you name the reason for the refresh, the evidence needed and the inputs for the brief; it does not set an automatic replacement date.

Quick summary

  1. What to know before deciding on an AV refresh
  2. Decision matrix for an AV refresh
  3. How to set the order of rooms and refresh phases
  4. What to keep and what to include in the replacement
  5. How to prepare a comparable refresh brief
  6. Frequently asked questions

What to know before deciding on an AV refresh

Start with what the room should enable for the people who will use it. Name the required use and how it differs from today. Then match it with the specific setup and what you know about it: device models, observed problems, the manufacturer’s support conditions and dependencies on other components.

Physical functionality, support, compatibility and suitability for the required use are different questions. A device may work but no longer be suitable once requirements change. As an illustration, imagine a camera that no longer covers the necessary shot after the seating layout changes. That change alone says nothing about the condition of the other parts of the room.

So for every reason to renew, also write down the evidence. For a fault, distinguish the observed symptom from the confirmed cause. For support, look for the conditions that apply to the specific model. If you don’t have a piece of information, mark it as missing. That way it stays clear whether the plan is based on a verified problem or still contains a question to be checked.

Age helps you open the assessment, but it does not determine its outcome. Typical PSNI intervals and their limits are explained in a separate article on AV equipment lifespan. For planning, you also need to know which parts of such an estimate apply to your setup and what they mean for the scope of work.

Stage with a blue LED wall and lighting trusses

Decision matrix for an AV refresh

Use the matrix for each room separately. In one row, write down the reason you are dealing with and attach the evidence you have. One room can have several reasons at the same time. The table therefore does not calculate a score or replace the assessment of the specific setup.

Reason to open a refreshWhat you need to documentConsequence for the plan or brief
You observe a fault or an unsatisfactory function.Record the symptom, the conditions under which it occurs and whether you already know the cause. Find out the options for repairing or replacing the affected part.Separate investigating the cause from ordering a solution. Derive the scope of replacement only from the findings and the dependencies on the rest of the setup.
The required use of the room is changing.Describe the new requirement and compare it with the capabilities of the specific setup. Name where it falls short today.Specify the required outcome and the parts affected by the change. Assess whether a partial refresh is enough or a broader intervention is needed.
The manufacturer is ending support for a specific device.Provide the manufacturer’s notice, the model, the scope of the ending support and the conditions your use must meet.Assess the impact on the given configuration. End of support alone does not mean a physical fault or the replacement of all devices.
You plan to connect retained and new equipment.Determine the exact models, the required compatibility, the available documentation and configuration, and the necessary adaptation.Compare a partial and a full refresh, including the work of connecting and reconfiguring. Do not automatically report keeping a part as a saving.
So far, the reason is age, a budget horizon or incomplete records.State the origin and conditions of the estimate. Fill in the missing information on condition, support and suitability for the required use.Separate the working budget assumption from the confirmed scope of the refresh. Keep missing data visible until it has been checked.

The output of the matrix should be a specific requirement or a specific question. If you have a documented fault, you can move on to assessing repair and replacement. If you only know the age of the device, the next step is to fill in the data. Uncertainty should lead to an investigation, because on its own it does not prove the need for a full replacement.

How to set the order of rooms and refresh phases

With several rooms, add to the matrix what each one is used for and what impact the documented problem has on that use. Also state whether you have a usable alternative. This information lets you explain the order to the colleagues who decide on the budget, instead of justifying it only by the purchase date.

When setting the order, I recommend separating interventions that are ready from those still missing evidence. Different use can lead to a different priority even when devices are of a similar age. At the same time, for every open point, decide who is to supply the missing information. Otherwise a working estimate can easily slip into procurement as a finished decision.

Also assess a phased refresh by the dependencies between retained and replaced parts. Each phase must name what will remain connected after it and what work that connection will require. Simply splitting the purchase into smaller amounts does not explain whether the chosen setup will be suitable.

That is why there is no universal rule to start with audio, the camera or the display. The order should follow from the required use and the documented problem. Then record the budget horizon as the organization’s plan; it is not a guarantee of how long individual devices will last.

Attendees of the PSNI Global Alliance anniversary meeting in front of a stage with the alliance logo

What to keep and what to include in the replacement

For each alternative you are considering, list the retained and replaced parts. For retained equipment, state the basis on which you count on its further use and what still needs to be checked. For a new part, also describe its dependencies on the existing setup, so that a list of products alone does not hide the necessary work.

Keeping, repair, partial refresh and full replacement make sense depending on the condition of the devices, support, compatibility and the availability of repair. If the existing setup meets the required use and you have evidence supporting its continued use, a full refresh may not be necessary. So do not commission a larger intervention just because of the age the equipment has reached.

The opposite assumption may not hold either. MediaTech generally does not recommend combining old AV technologies with new ones, because the resulting cost can be higher than with a new solution and long-term compatibility is uncertain. It depends on the age, the type of technology and the scope of the project. When deciding, compare the adaptation and reconfiguration of retained parts as well, not just the price of the new device.

Assess maintenance by the specific work required. On its own, it may not resolve incompatibility, restore ended support or secure an unavailable part. A recommendation to “keep servicing it” therefore needs evidence just as specific as a recommendation to replace.

How to prepare a comparable refresh brief

Send suppliers the same description of the rooms, the required use and known problems. Add the exact devices the design should take into account, and the open questions from the matrix. That makes it clear which inputs you already know and where you expect an investigation before the scope is finalized.

You can use the following as working wording for the brief:

For each room, state the retained and replaced parts and the evidence on which this scope is based. Separate confirmed facts from assumptions and questions to be checked. Describe the necessary connection, adaptation and configuration, as well as the work involved in the replacement. State what the price includes and what remains outside it. If you propose alternatives, compare them for the same required use and the same time horizon.

When reviewing bids, check whether they solve the same task. A cheaper device does not necessarily mean a cheaper replacement if one total is missing necessary work. So have the differences in scope explained before you rank the final prices. Do not treat a missing item as a zero cost.

Take the same approach to support and service: ask what exactly the conditions cover. Accepting a request, a technician’s arrival and fixing a fault are different events. If a bid promises any of them, you need to know what it actually means and under which conditions when you compare bids.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to renew all meeting rooms of the same age at once? The same age alone does not determine the same scope or order of renewal. Compare the required use, documented condition, support and dependencies of each setup. For phases, also assess how the retained and new parts will work together.

Is the end of support a reason to replace the whole room immediately? End of support alone does not mean the device has physically failed. You need to know what the manufacturer stops supporting and what impact that has on the specific configuration and your conditions of use. Determine the scope of the refresh only from this assessment.

Should we start by renewing the audio? Start with the documented problem and the required use of the room. A universal order of audio, video and control would bypass the condition of the specific setup. So before purchasing, name what the intervention should solve and which parts it concerns.

What should we do if we don’t know the exact models or the support status of the devices? Record the missing data for the given room and decide who will check it. Mark the working budget as an assumption until you have evidence for its scope. Incomplete records alone do not prove the need for a full replacement.

Can a partial refresh be compared with a full replacement? Yes, if both proposals address the same required use and list the retained parts as well as all the necessary work. Compare them over the same time horizon and with uncertainties kept visible. The price of the devices alone is not enough for such a decision.

CONTACT US

Contact our specialist or fill out a short form. We will contact you back.

OR FILL OUT A SHORT FORM

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    WordPress Lightbox